Olive Garden Desserts Menu With Prices (2026): 7 Desserts, Calories & Best Picks

You made it past the breadsticks, the salad, and a plate of pasta. Now the question is whether dessert is worth it — and which one. This guide covers the 7 desserts on the menu right now, with prices by city, calories, and honest picks from two professional tastings and hundreds of customer posts — plus the 2 desserts people keep asking for even though they are gone, Zeppoli and Dolcini. Start with the full Olive Garden menu for the whole picture.
Quick Answer
Olive Garden has 7 desserts in 2026: Chocolate Lasagna, Black Tie Mousse Cake, Tiramisu, Strawberry Cream Cake, Warm Italian Doughnuts, Sicilian Cheesecake, and the limited-time Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake. Prices run 8.49–12.49 by city; calories run 470–980 per serving. Best by consensus — two professional tastings and the most-recommended pick in customer posts — is the Black Tie Mousse Cake. Lightest is Tiramisu at 470 calories; heaviest is Chocolate Lasagna at 980. Zeppoli and Dolcini are not on the menu anymore.
Key Facts for 2026
- Desserts on the menu now: 7 (6 everyday + 1 limited-time Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake)
- Price range: 8.49–12.49, varies by city — never a single national price
- Calorie range: 470–980 per serving
- Lightest: Tiramisu, 1 slice, 470 cal
- Heaviest: Chocolate Lasagna, 980 cal
- Best overall: Black Tie Mousse Cake (top-2 in both professional tastings, most recommended by customers)
- All 7 desserts are marked (V) vegetarian
- No gluten-free dessert on the current menu
- Zeppoli and Dolcini: discontinued, still heavily searched
- Checked: November 2026, against the official Olive Garden menu, live three-city price research, and two independent tastings

Olive Garden Desserts Menu With Prices (2026)

Chocolate Lasagna (V)
USD 9.49–12.29 | 980 cal
the heaviest dessert on the menu. Eight layers of chocolate cake, mousse, crushed wafers, and chocolate sauce, with white chocolate grated on top. A video review calls it “worth going off your diet for a day.” Get the sauce on the side for takeout.

Black Tie Mousse Cake (V)
USD 9.79–12.49 | 750 cal
the best dessert on the menu. Chocolate cake layered with dark chocolate cheesecake, custard mousse, and ganache. All four Serious Eats testers agreed it was the best dessert on the table; Tasting Table ranked it second of six.

Tiramisu (V)
USD 9.29–11.99 | 470 cal
the lightest dessert on the menu. Espresso-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone cream and cocoa. Creamy, soft, and buttery, and at 470 calories a slice it is the only dessert under 500.

Strawberry Cream Cake (V)
USD 9.49–12.29 | 540 cal
the sleeper pick. Vanilla sponge cake with sweet vanilla cream and strawberry topping. Light, airy, and moist — one server compared it to tres leches — and third of six at Tasting Table. A regular’s tip: skip the strawberry, go with whipped cream.

Warm Italian Doughnuts (V)
USD 8.49–11.49 | 810 cal
the best warm dessert. Fluffy doughnuts rolled in vanilla sugar, served warm with chocolate or raspberry dipping sauce — ask for both. First of six at Tasting Table. Eat them straight away: the warmth is half the appeal. The only dessert served hot.

Sicilian Cheesecake with Strawberry Topping
USD 9.29–11.99 | 700 cal
the weakest of the seven. Ricotta cheesecake on a shortbread crust with strawberry sauce. Dense, smooth, and rich, but last of six at Tasting Table — plain-looking, and the crust could use more crunch.

Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake
USD 9.29–11.99 | 620 cal
the seasonal one. The new fall cheesecake, marked NEW and limited time on the official menu. Customers love it: “we had it last year too! for my birthday, my GM gave me a whole cake since it was out of season lol, it’s definitely my favorite dessert we have.”
Olive Garden Dessert Prices by Location
There is no single Olive Garden dessert price. The same slice costs about $3 less in Atlanta and Dallas than in New York — live three-city research captured from Olive Garden’s own pickup menu on October 1, 2026 proves it. Both prices are real. Check the app for your local restaurant before you order.
| Dessert | Atlanta / Dallas | Mid set | New York / official online menu |
| Chocolate Lasagna (V) | $9.49 | $10.29 | $12.29 |
| Black Tie Mousse Cake (V) | $9.79 | $10.49 | $12.49 |
| Tiramisu (V) | $9.29 | $9.99 | $11.99 |
| Strawberry Cream Cake (V) | $9.49 | $10.29 | $12.29 |
| Warm Italian Doughnuts (V) | $8.49 | $9.99 | $11.49 |
| Sicilian Cheesecake (V) | $9.29 | $9.99 | $11.99 |
| Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake (V) | $9.29 | — | $11.99 |
The most expensive is the Black Tie at up to $12.49; the cheapest is the doughnuts at $8.49 in the low-price cities. The gap is why the loudest complaint in customer posts — 491 votes — calls $10 a slice “ridiculous.” At Atlanta prices the Black Tie at $9.79 is an easy yes; at New York prices, a $12.49 decision.
Olive Garden Desserts Calories and Nutrition
Calories do not vary by city. The numbers below are the official menu values, checked November 2026. Two corrections: Sicilian Cheesecake is 700 calories, not 910 as one stale table claims, and Chocolate Lasagna is 980 — the 820 figure belongs to the old Chocolate Brownie Lasagna.
| Dessert | Serving | Calories |
| Tiramisu (V) | 1 slice | 470 |
| Strawberry Cream Cake (V) | 1 slice | 540 |
| Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake (V) | 1 slice | 620 |
| Sicilian Cheesecake (V) | 1 slice | 700 |
| Black Tie Mousse Cake (V) | 1 slice | 750 |
| Warm Italian Doughnuts (V) | 1 order | 810 |
| Chocolate Lasagna (V) | 1 slice | 980 |
Tiramisu is the only dessert under 500 calories — the honest pick after a heavy entrée. Chocolate Lasagna at 980 is more than double the Tiramisu: a dessert for two. The doughnuts at 810 surprise people: they look light, they are not. The gap between lightest and heaviest here is 510 calories — a whole extra course.
What Is the Best Dessert at Olive Garden?
Two professional tastings and hundreds of customer posts point the same way. Sources labelled.
1. Black Tie Mousse Cake. Unanimous best at Serious Eats (14 desserts), second of six at Tasting Table, most-recommended in first-timer threads.
2. Warm Italian Doughnuts. First of six at Tasting Table. Warm, fluffy, not too sweet; raspberry sauce the better pairing.
3. Strawberry Cream Cake. Third of six at Tasting Table, the sleeper pick in customer posts. Best choice if you do not want coffee or chocolate.
4. Tiramisu. Nobody disliked it, but neither tasting ranked it at the top. The lightest dessert on the menu and the safe pick after a heavy meal.
5. Chocolate Lasagna. The most talked-about and the most divided. Fifth of six at Tasting Table, but the most-mentioned dessert in customer posts.
6. Sicilian Cheesecake. Last of six at Tasting Table. Rich and creamy, but plain, dense, and the least memorable of the seven.
7. Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake. Not ranked — it is seasonal — but the loudest customer favourite, with a 9-out-of-10 video rating.
Best Dessert for Every Mood
| Situation | Pick | Why |
| Lightest finish | Tiramisu | 470 cal, the only dessert under 500 |
| Heaviest, built for sharing | Chocolate Lasagna | 980 cal, 8 layers, split it |
| Best chocolate | Black Tie Mousse Cake | Darker, richer, unanimous best |
| Best warm dessert | Warm Italian Doughnuts | Served hot, raspberry sauce |
Are Olive Garden Desserts Made Fresh or Frozen?
No. The desserts arrive frozen, made by an outside company, and the restaurant plates them. That is not a rumour — employees say so directly in customer posts: “You take the frozen cake and put it on a plastic tray with a lid and put that in the dessert cooler. That’s it.”
That is the honest context for the price: 9.49–12.49 a slice for a dessert made elsewhere and thawed in the restaurant. If fresh-made dessert matters to you, know this before you order.
Olive Garden Birthday Dessert: What Actually Happens
The birthday dessert is the most-asked dessert question online, and the answer is messier than the official line. Verified: Olive Garden’s eClub sends members a complimentary birthday dessert coupon — one LinkedIn post from September 2025 describes it arriving and exceeding expectations. A separate customer post reports the opposite: the email coupon expired when they tried to use it ordering online. Sign up for eClub at least a week before your birthday and read the coupon’s expiry date. Reported by customers and employees, not confirmed officially: “Olive Garden will never ask for ID for free birthday desserts.” “Just say it’s your birthday and we’ll give it to you.” “Any of the desserts can be your birthday dessert.” One server wrote they would give “as many free desserts as they want as long as they mention the word birthday.” That is practice, not policy. One post from Regina, Canada reports the expected free dessert not happening at all. Join eClub, bring the coupon, and ask your server.
Can You Buy a Whole Cake From Olive Garden?
No menu site answers this. Olive Garden does not list whole cakes on its dessert menu, but customers report buying them — one post says a general manager gave them a whole Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake out of season for a birthday. Those are customer reports, not a published price list. If you want a whole cake, call your local restaurant and ask, including about dessert party trays for events.
Gluten-Free and Dietary Options
There is no gluten-free dessert on the current menu. All 7 desserts are marked (V) vegetarian, and none carries a gluten-free mark. The old gluten-free option, the Flourless Chocolate Torte, was discontinued. Some menu sites still suggest sorbets or fruit-based desserts — those are not on the current menu either, so do not order from that advice. For allergies: one customer post reports there are no nut products in the Olive Garden kitchen and the desserts come from an outside company frozen — a user claim, not an official statement. Customer posts say managers come out and verify an allergy in person — tell your server and ask for the manager.
Zeppoli and Dolcini: Gone From the Menu
Two desserts people still search for every week are not on the menu anymore — and every stale menu site still lists them.
Zeppoli. Warm Italian-style doughnuts, dusted with sugar, with a chocolate dipping sauce. Older lists showed one order at 760 calories. The Serious Eats tasting in 2023 ranked them the worst of the bunch — bread-like texture, hard chewy bottoms, watery chocolate sauce. They were replaced by the Warm Italian Doughnuts: softer, fluffier, with a choice of chocolate or raspberry sauce. If you miss Zeppoli, order the doughnuts. That is the current version.
Dolcini. Mini desserts in little cups — lemon cream, dark chocolate, and strawberry and white chocolate, with the Serious Eats “Piccoli Dolci” tasting listing five flavours in all. In 2023 they cost $3.29 each, or three for $7.79. They are gone. One customer post gives the reason: “The dolcini’s are gone due to a supply chain disruption. The distributor could no longer keep up with the demand.” That is a user claim, but the disappearance is a fact — no Dolcini on the menu, and no mini dessert option at all. The lightest full dessert now is the Tiramisu at 470 calories.
Also gone: Lemon Cream Cake (470 on older lists), Chocolate Brownie Lasagna (820), Cannoli Trio (770), Flourless Chocolate Torte (570), Zabaglione with berries, Buttercream Cake and Cookie Butter Cake, and a mint dessert one customer post calls “incredibly short lived.”
How We Checked
- Official Olive Garden menu, checked November 2026: all 7 current items, prices, and calories — the source for the item list. It also corrects stale pages: Sicilian Cheesecake is 700 calories, not 910; Chocolate Lasagna is 980, not 820; Strawberry Cream Cake is not “Strawberry Shortcake.”
- Live three-city price research, October 1, 2026: prices captured from Olive Garden’s own pickup menu in Atlanta, Dallas, and New York. That is the source for the price-by-city table and the reason this page gives ranges, not one price.
- Two independent tastings: Serious Eats (September 2023, 14 desserts) and Tasting Table (January 2025, 6 desserts, tasted the same day, re-tasted at home, takeout test). Rankings are labelled with their source.
- Customer posts, labelled as claims: Reddit threads, YouTube reviews, and Facebook video reviews supplied the language, tips, and sentiment — the caramel drizzle, the raspberry sauce, the birthday stories, the frozen-cake reports. Vote counts are engagement evidence, not proof.
- What is not in this page: no Semrush data arrived for this topic, so none is claimed. No invented prices, calories, or dates. Where the answer is not confirmed — the whole-cake question, the takeout coupon question, the gluten-free question — this page says so instead of guessing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What desserts does Olive Garden have?
Seven in 2026: Chocolate Lasagna, Black Tie Mousse Cake, Tiramisu, Strawberry Cream Cake, Warm Italian Doughnuts, Sicilian Cheesecake with Strawberry Topping, and the limited-time Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake — all marked (V) vegetarian.
What is the best dessert at Olive Garden?
The Black Tie Mousse Cake. It was the unanimous best in the Serious Eats tasting, second of six in the Tasting Table ranking, and the most-recommended dessert in customer posts. Ask for a caramel drizzle.
How big is the Tiramisu, and how many calories does it have?
One slice, 470 calories — the lightest dessert on the menu — at 9.29–11.99 depending on the city. Espresso-soaked ladyfingers with mascarpone cream and cocoa. There is no alcohol in it, according to a restaurant manager.
How many calories are in the Chocolate Lasagna?
980 calories per slice — the heaviest dessert on the menu, more than double the Tiramisu. It is eight layers of chocolate cake, mousse, crushed wafers, and chocolate sauce. It is built for sharing.
Does Olive Garden still have Zeppoli?
No. Zeppoli were discontinued and replaced by the Warm Italian Doughnuts — softer, fluffier, with chocolate or raspberry dipping sauce. Older lists showed Zeppoli at 760 calories an order.
What happened to the Dolcini?
They are gone. Dolcini were mini desserts in little cups — lemon cream, dark chocolate, strawberry and white chocolate — at $3.29 each in 2023. One customer post blames a supply chain disruption. There is no mini dessert on the current menu.
Is there a free birthday dessert at Olive Garden?
Olive Garden’s eClub sends members a complimentary birthday dessert coupon — sign up at least a week before your birthday and check the coupon’s expiry date. Customers and employees also report that saying it is your birthday often gets a free dessert with no ID checked. Those are claims, not official policy, and one report says the expected free dessert did not happen. Join eClub and ask your server.
Can I buy a whole cake from Olive Garden?
There is no whole-cake price on the dessert menu, but customers report buying whole cakes, including a whole Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake given by a general manager for a birthday. Call your local restaurant and ask, including about dessert party trays.
Are Olive Garden desserts made fresh or frozen?
Frozen. Employees report the desserts arrive in boxes from an outside company and are plated in the restaurant — which is why the quality is consistent, and why the $10-a-slice price draws complaints.
Does Olive Garden have gluten-free desserts?
No gluten-free dessert is on the current menu. All seven desserts are marked (V) vegetarian only. The old gluten-free option, the Flourless Chocolate Torte, was discontinued. Tell your server about any allergy and ask for the manager.
Does Olive Garden have ice cream?
No ice cream is on the current dessert menu. If you want something cold and light, the closest option is the Tiramisu at 470 calories.
Is the Pumpkin Cookie Butter Cheesecake limited time?
Yes. It is marked NEW and limited time on the official menu, at 620 calories and 9.29–11.99 depending on the city. It comes back around September — one customer post heard September 22 — and leaves when the season ends. Call first.
Bottom Line
Seven desserts, one clear winner, and a price that depends on your city. Order the Black Tie Mousse Cake for the best dessert, the Warm Italian Doughnuts for something hot and fun, the Tiramisu for the lightest finish, and the Chocolate Lasagna to share the richest thing on the menu. Check the app for your local prices first — the same slice can cost $8.49 in one city and $12.49 in another. Going for a birthday? Join eClub first; that is the one free dessert route that is verified. Skip the pages still listing Zeppoli, Dolcini, and Lemon Cream Cake as current. They are gone, and this page is the one that says so.
